Continuing
Escalation of
Anti-Minority Incidents in Vojvodina
September 2004
Prepared
for the
Human Dimension Implementation Meeting of the
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
October 4-15, 2004, Warsaw, Poland
|
Hungarian
Human Rights Foundation (HHRF) is an international human
rights organization which, for the past 28 years, has
monitored the human rights condition of the 3 million
Hungarians who live as minorities in Romania, Slovakia,
Serbia-Montenegro, Ukraine Croatia and Slovenia. In accordance
with its purpose, HHRF regularly collects, translates,
analyses and disseminates reliable reports on the human
rights condition of these communities. With offices in
North America and Europe, the Foundation serves as a clearinghouse
of information for Western governments, human rights organizations,
the media and the public. |
|
I. Introduction
The
harassment and physical assault of non-ethnic Serbs including
children, threats against ethnic Hungarian and pro-autonomy leaders,
desecration of cemeteries, vandalism of property and the proliferation
of racist, xenophobic and anti-Semitic graffiti are becoming near
daily occurrences in the province of Vojvodina. 300,000 strong,
and comprising 14 percent of the population, ethnic Hungarians
are the largest national minority in this multi-ethnic region.
As
HHRF's expanded -- by no means exhaustive -- chronological report
indicates, radicalization of Serbian society, especially within
the multi-ethnic province of Vojvodina, has been on the rise for
the past 1 1/2 years, and intensified since Fall 2003. The underlying
motivation seems to be misdirected venting of the majority's frustrations
against minorities (innocent bystanders) over the "loss of Kosovo."
The components of this increasing tendency of intolerance consist
of, among others:
1. Failure
by the authorities to acknowledge and curb anti-minority sentiments
and acts
2. Overt
provocations by Serbian radical elements within the echelons of
power, and
3. Ongoing
disparity between the native population and hundreds of thousands
of resettled ethnic Serbian refugees from Croatia, Bosnia and
Kosovo.
Official
Responses to the Incidents
The
overwhelming response by Serbian authorities to reports of minority-related
violence, desecration, vandalism and incitement to hatred is evasion,
minimization and low-balling of the number of incidents. Different
government officials have given varying figures regarding the
number of anti-minority incidents ranging from a total of three
to 300 in 2004 alone. This fact alone is a telling indicator of
the reluctance to even assess the extent and scope of the situation.
Only
after U.S. Congressman Tom Lantos' July 9, 2004 letter to Serbian
Prime Minister Vojislav Kostunica in which he asked the "government
[to] take immediate action to curb those Serbian elements in Vojvodina
which are targeting Hungarian and other minorities as scapegoats,"
did the prime minister invite ethnic Hungarian leaders to meet
with him in Belgrade. Following all-day discussions on July 13,
Kostunica agreed to create two committees, one to investigate
anti-minority incidents and another to establish and evaluate
projects to prevent further incidents. To date, neither has been
done. At that time, the prime minister also said he would shortly
visit towns in Vojvodina with larger Hungarian populations as
well as the editorial offices of the only Hungarian-language daily
Magyar Szó.
After
two postponements, on September 8, Kostunica did in fact visit
the province. The prime minister's pronouncements reflected previously
voiced official attitudes which include (1) admonishing minorities
that the situation will grow worse if they continue to "go abroad"
with their plight; (2) side-stepping the issues by concentrating
on linguistic subtleties such as the word "atrocity" not existing
in the Serbian language; and (3) attributing unspecified "political
motivations" to ethnic Hungarian leaders for voicing concern over
burgeoning violence.
The
Police Force: Part of the Problem
The
situation is compounded by the police authorities' reactions to
incidents of assault. The Hungarian community's sense of despair
is heightened by the fact that in many instances the very forces
which should be providing protection and recourse instead (1)
are slow to come to the scene of attacks, (2) minimize the severity
of the incidents, (3) dismiss the ethnic motivations of attacks
by attributing them to merely drunken behavior, (4) fail to rigorously
pursue and conclude investigations and (5) are not unknown to
be the instigators of unprovoked assault themselves. A shocking
example is the case of the mayor of Padé/Padej, ethnic
Hungarian László Komáromi, who reported
that on August 20, 2004 the local police chief of Csóka/Čoka,
Ivan Mijandzic, twice slapped him without cause while on
official business in the police station.
The
total number of incidents reported in HHRF's expanded chronology
is merely 70 and includes all follow-up information we've be able
to obtain on police investigations and their degree of effectiveness;
merely a fraction of the cases have reached the court level. It
is interesting to note that the authorities have been much more
effective in their investigations when the victims were ethnic
Serbs. A case in point is one Zoran Petrovic, who was brutally
beaten up by five ethnic Hungarians in Temerin and suffered very
severe injuries. In this case, the police found the assailants
immediately, and on September 23, 2004 newspapers announced that
charges have been filed. Another case was the murder of a police
officer in the 80 percent Hungarian-inhabited village of Csantavér/Cantavir.
All state media reported the case, insinuating that the murderer
was surely an ethnic Hungarian. The police soon found the shooter,
who turned out to be Serbian; however, no Serbian-language newspaper
has yet to report this development.
Plans
by the national government to establish a National Minority Council
include the review of police effectiveness and the creation of
a multi-ethnic police force, two timely and much-needed measures.
In
sum, in order to curb and prevent future incidents, at minimum,
a task force needs to be created with national and provincial
components to (1) urgently and thoroughly access the situation,
(2) gather data from diverse sources, (3) swiftly investigate
and prosecute, and (4) formulate and implement a multi-tiered,
broad-based short and long-term strategy for the cessation of
anti-minority hostilities and the prevention of future incidents.
II. Harassment
and Physical Assaults against Non-Serb Minorities; Threats against
Ethnic Hungarian and Pro-Autonomy Leaders
|
The
intimidation, harassment and physical assault of ethnic
Hungarian children by ethnic Serbian children -- often
times for speaking Hungarian -- is occurring with alarming
frequency. For example, the incidents of January 31 and
November 13, 2003 pointedly show that these acts are ethnically
motivated. In the first, a bus driver shouted and cursed
at young students for speaking in Hungarian and chastised
their teacher for not teaching them "proper culture and
language." In the latter, four students who were pummeling
another stopped after it turned out the victim's last
name was Serbian and that they would not "hurt one of
their own people."
The
number of incidents is underreported both by the victims
and the authorities who tend to minimize their severity
and ethnic motivation, and are not unknown to blame the
victims for "provoking" the attacks. In the case of the
former, a general atmosphere of fear is pervasive among
minorities. As the mother of one of one of the victim's
said:
"hate-speech
is common in the fights that take place between Serbian
and Hungarian teenagers both in the school and on the
street... ethnic Hungarian children are afraid to inform
their parents or other adults because they fear further
violence. Parents feel desperate because they believe
that Serbian authorities will not intervene." [see report
of March 12, 2004]
When
a police captain slaps an ethnic Hungarian mayor in a
police station, without provocation, as happened on August
20 of this year, this fear is well-founded. Police are
generally slow to come to the scene and according to HHRF's
information, have successfully followed up in only 13
cases we have reported.
|
|
NEW
September 28, 2004
An
ethnic Hungarian high school student, E.N., was beaten
for smiling at a Serbian fellow student on the bus. The ethnic
Hungarian boy from Bácsfeketehegy/Feketic, and the Serbian
boy from Szikics/Lovcenac, were both traveling on the 6.30 a.m.
bus of the Topolatrans Bus Company to the agricultural high school
in Bácstopolya/Backa Topola when the incident happened.
According to eyewitnesses and the victim, the Serbian boy said:
"No Hungarian has ever smiled at me and none will ever do!"
and then proceeded to punch E.N. Several other boys started to
punch E.N. as well and when two of his friends tried to help him,
all were beaten. E.N. suffered several bruises and injuries. The
case was reported to the local self-government as well as the
police. Károly Pál, Chairman of the Executive
Committee of Bácstopolya municipality told reporters at
the Hungarian-language daily Magyar Szó that the
police have already investigated the incident, identified the
aggressors and filed charges against them. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), September 29, 2004]
NEW
September 27 and 28, 2004
A
fight broke out among several students of the technical high school
in Temerin on September 28. The previous day an ethnic Hungarian
student, L. N., had found the wallet of an ethnic Serbian
girl from the school and returned it to her. The girl later accused
L.N. of stealing 200 Dinars (approx. $3) from the wallet. Ten
students from the girl's class came over during recess and started
demanding the missing money. L.N. and his friends showed them
their empty pockets as a sign of good will. The Serb students
left, but after 10 minutes came back, saying that L.N. should
apologize. The boy refused to do so, as he did not have a reason.
A Serbian boy hit L.N. and a small fight started between the two
boys. During the fight Cs. M., another ethnic Hungarian
student, also got hit. When the break was over, all involved returned
to their respective classrooms and went home at the end of the
school day.
The
next day, on September 28, the taunting continued. G. K.
and A. P. gave a first-hand account of the encounter to
Béla Csorba, Vice-President of the Hungarian Democratic
Party of Vojvodina (VMDP) from Temerin, who transcribed the events
for HHRF. This is how G. K. remembers the case:
"During
recess, about 30 boys gathered in the schoolyard, some of them
with baseball bats, taunting us. When they left school at the
end of the day, L.N. and another boy, stuck with two teachers
and the group did not follow them. Instead, the group came after
us, as we headed towards the park. There were only eight of us,
so we started to run. I stumbled and fell; they overwhelmed me
and started to kick me while I was on the ground. They kept asking
me: "What happened to the wallet?", "Where is the money?", "What
are you [Hungarians] doing here? This is our land!" My wallet
fell out; they searched it, and after taking a few less important
papers, gave it back. Adults walking by came closer to help, so
our attackers fled. However, one of them was too slow, I caught
him, and hit him a couple of times because I felt very desperate
and hurt by what had just happened to me. His friends saw this
and came back, but by that time, my friends had arrived with branches
from the nearby trees. Someone tried to call the police station,
but no one picked up the phone. We walked to the police station
with a friend of mine, E. P., and I called my mother on
my cellular."
At
the police station, the boys recounted the incident to three officers
and stated that they felt there was an ethnic motivation to the
attack. One of the police officer's dismissed the ethnic taunts
recounted by the victim with "You must have provoked them."
The officers also expressed doubts that 30 people would have attacked
one person. Lajos Miskolci, senior police officer, asked
G.K. to show his injuries and after seeing them retorted "This
is nothing." The mother of G.K., who was present at the hearing,
told them: "I didn't expect this kind of attitude from the
police," and took her son to the local medical center for
evaluation. [First-Hand Account Taken in Temerin for HHRF by Béla
Csorba, Vice-President of the Hungarian Democratic Party
of Vojvodina (VMDP) on September 28, 2004]
August
23, 2004
The
ethnic Hungarian mayor of Szabadka/Subotica, Géza Kucsera,
is the latest victim of threatening telephone calls. On Monday,
he received a message on his official answering machine from an
unidentified man summoning him to the headquarters of the extremist
Serbian Radical Party to "pick up a package from The Hague" and
sing a belligerent fascist Chetnik song. It should be noted that
Serbian Radical Party leader Vojislav Seselj, now on trial for
war crimes in The Hague, considers himself the new Chetnik Vojvod.
The Mayor exclaimed indignation at the affront to his character
and said he will file a police complaint. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), August 24, 2004]
Updated
August 22, 2004
At
3:30 a.m., a group of ethnic Serbian youth assaulted two ethnic
Hungarian teenagers in front of the Hotel Patria, near the Croatian
Consulate, in downtown Szabadka/Subotica. The two boys -- 19-year
old Denisz Sötét and another wishing to remain
anonymous -- were getting off a bus in the company of others,
at a bus stop. Shortly thereafter, a dark gray Mitsubishi pulled
up and five young men jumped out. They told the two teenagers
that they were looking for someone called "Zsolt." When they realized
that neither of the two boys was the sought individual, one of
them shouted: "It doesn't matter, these are also Hungarians,
so let's beat them!" The gang started to brutally beat and
kick the two boys while others around them fled. Denisz Sötét
was dragged to the front garden of the Hotel Patria, and kicked
severely while lying on the ground. In the meantime, the guard
standing at the nearby Croatian Consulate remained idle, and did
the dozen of guests celebrating a wedding in the hotel and privy
to the incident, recounted Sötét's father later to
reporters. When the assailants left, Sötét and his
friend crawled to the guard patrolling the Hungarian Consulate
a few hundred meters from the scene who called the police immediately.
Soon, six to eight policemen arrived at the scene. However, instead
of trying to catch the perpetrators who were getting into the
car which was still at the bus stop, the police officers kept
questioning the ethnic Hungarian teenagers about the incident.
Sötét's father later reported to the Hungarian language
daily Magyar Szó that after arriving to the
scene, he overheard one of the policemen say: "Enough of this
nonsense that Serbs are beating Hungarians. I do not want to deal
with this. Anyway, one or two smacks are not such a big deal."
Sötét suffered serious bruises; head, face and abdominal
injuries. Police escorted him to the hospital, but in the absence
of an acting surgeon, Sötét was told to go home and
come back if his pains continued. In a September 8 interview with
Magyar Szó, Szabadka's police chief, Borivoj Mucalj,
stated that after having investigated 90 Mitsubishis, police found
the gray car belonging to the perpetrators. He also said that
the police identified the assailants: two minors. No further details
have been released. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), August 23, September 18 and 19, 2004; Vajdaság
MA -- Délvidék Hírportál (www.vajdasagma.info),
August 23, 2004; Népszabadság (Budapest),
August 24, 2004; Magyar Hírlap (Budapest),
August 24, 2004]
August
20, 2004
In
Csóka/Čoka, local police chief Ivan Mijandzic physically
assaulted the mayor of Padé/Padej, ethnic Hungarian László
Komáromi, at the police station. The victim said he
had no explanation as to why the police officer slapped him twice
on his face. He told the Hungarian-language daily Magyar
Szó that the incident occurred between 9:15-9:30
a.m. when he went to the police station to procure certificates
necessary for running in the upcoming local elections in September.
Komáromi is a member of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina
and is on the party list for the post of local councilman in Padé.
While he was waiting for the document certifying that he is a
resident of Padé, a police officer told him that the police
chief wanted him in his office. When Komáromi entered the
room, the police chief started to arrogantly question him about
why he wanted to damage inter-ethnic relations and who he thought
he was. Komáromi replied that he is a taxpaying citizen
of the country and is on official business at the police station.
When the police chief threatened him again, the mayor said: "Sir,
whatever your intention are, act according to the law and police
regulations." Mijandzic responded by slapping Komáromi
twice on the face, yelled at him to get out, and ultimately shoved
him out of his office. After the incident, Komáromi went
to the Zenta/Senta hospital where he was examined. The medical
report states that the victim suffered a highly visible suffusion
of blood and the incident has affected his nervous system as well.
Five days after the incident, the Csóka police station
still refused to comment on the event. At the inquiry of the Hungarian
daily, Népszabadság, police said that
an official statement could be obtained at the central police
station in Nagykikinda/Kikinda. However, the head of the Nagykikinda
police station was said to be out of the office when sought. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), August 24,
2004; Népszabadság (Budapest) August
25, 2004]
July
30, 2004
Around
3:00 a.m. a fight broke out in Csantavér/Cantavir between
four young men: Siniąa Ćulum and Duąko Maljković
of Újfény/Novi ®ednik, and Róbert Dudás and
Kornél Nagy of Óbecse/Becej. Police
were able to intervene quickly, thereby preventing serious injury.
The initiators, Ćulum and Maljković, were charged with
a misdemeanor for "disturbing the peace." The conflict was probably
ethnically-based since the victims reported the assailants shouting:
"What are you doing here? Go home! We're going to kill you!"
upon hearing the two speaking in Hungarian. "I have never participated
in a fight, not to mention an inter-ethnic one. I have had a Serbian
girlfriend now for two years. I have many Serbian friends; none
of them have ever treated me this way," said Dudás.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
August 3, 2004]
July
30, 2004
Similar
to the incident in Törökkanizsa/Novi Knezevac on May
30, violence erupted in Szabadka/Subotica at a 17 year-old boy's
private birthday party. After four uninvited ethnic Serbian boys
bullied their way onto the premises around 11 p.m., and objected
the Hungarian music being played, approximately 30 members of
well-known neighborhood gang returned. The gang broke down the
door, proceeded to destroy bottles, hitting people over the head
with them, and damage music equipment and other property inside
the rented space. At least five of the party participants had
to be hospitalized. The police arrived late after the mother of
one of the boys called them to the scene. Asking to remain anonymous
for fear of reprisals, she recounted the events to reporters:
My older son [aged 29] managed to dial us up on his cellular
before he passed out. We called the police station. We were told
that they had no available cars at the time and we should dial
another number. We called the other number, told them about the
situation, and hurried to the spot. I saw both my sons covered
with blood. The streets were covered with blood."
"By
the time we arrived, only three of the attackers remained at the
scene," continued the mother. "I started shouting to them; the
police told me to behave. One policeman insinuated that there
had been alcohol consumption and no supervision. I told him, in
vain, that there were five adults present at the party. I find
it unbelievable that soon we will have to hire private security
detail in order to guard Hungarian private events," concluded
the visibly shaken mother. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), August 2, 2004]
July
3, 2004
At
11:00 p.m., four 17-18 year-old ethnic Serbian perpetrators (C.S.
born 1987, A.V. born 1987, P.K. and Velibor Vulikic
born 1984) attacked four 16- to 17-year-old ethnic Hungarians
(T.A. born 1988, P.S. born 1989, A.E. and B.E.
born 1988) in the so-called „Fighter's line-up" district of Szabadka/Subotica,
an area inhabited mainly by Serbian refugees from Kosovo and Bosnia.
One of the victims said that the Serbians attacked without provocation,
shouting „Kecske, kecske" (goat, goat), an abbreviated
version of a popular anti-Hungarian slogan. T.A. was hospitalized
for internal bleeding, facial fractions and kidney bruises. The
incident happened at 69-71 Joó Lajos Street in a parking
lot. Police conducted a swift investigation and detained all perpetrators
on July 7. The official police press release stated that P.K.
and P.S., minors, are well-known to the authorities as delinquents.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
July 7 and 8, 2004]
June
14, 2004
Seventeen
year-old ethnic Hungarian student Krisztián Börcsök
said unknown assailants attacked him on an empty street of Keresztúr/
Ruski Krstur at 1:00 p.m. The victim was riding his bicycle home
from school in the nearby village of Törökkanizsa/Novi
Knezevac when he was attacked and beaten in the face several times.
There were no witnesses. Börcsök had to be hospitalized
for his injuries. A police investigation is currently underway.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
June 16, 2004]
The
Újvidék/Novi Sad Ministry of Interior office issued
a press release regarding three perpetrators who had attacked
two high school students from Óbecse/Becej on June 6, 2004
at 1:00 a.m. [see report of June 6]. The aggressors -- Dragan
Radivojevic (born 1985), R.P. (born 1986) and M.S.
(born 1989) -- were minors under the influence of alcohol.
One of their victims was repeatedly beaten on the face and body.
The press release, however, failed to mention that the attack
had ethnic overtones. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), June 17, 2004]
June
6, 2004
Unknown
perpetrators attacked two ethnic Hungarian minors, Szabolcs
Pap (born 1987) and Kazimir Korolija (born 1987) on
Petar Drapsin Street in Óbecse/Becej shortly after midnight.
The victims were riding home on their bicycles when they passed
a gang of young men standing near the road. Suddenly, someone
from the group started running after the bikers to inquire about
the time. Since only one of them had a watch, they started to
speak in Hungarian. Szabolcs Pap gave a first-hand account of
what happened next:
"By
then the boy who had asked about the time reached my side and
kicked the rear wheel of my bicycle. First I lost my balance and
then fell off the bike and hit a pile of bricks at the edge of
the road. I was lying on the ground when the boy started kicking
me and immediately three of his companions came over to beat me.
They loudly cursed my mother and told me to get away from this
place, I have no business being here. Since my friend, who stopped
his bicycle a bit further, saw that I was overwhelmed, he started
shouting for help in both Serbian and Hungarian. Upon hearing
the noise, a man and a woman came out from a nearby house and
shouted at the crowd beating me. Only then did they begin to loosen
their grip around me, so my friend could get to me and help me
escape. We started running toward a bridge, leaving our bicycles
behind. Only when we turned around and saw that no one was following
us did we stop, and I called my father on my cellular phone."
Pap
added that by the following day he was covered with bruises and
injuries all over his body. The physician László
Kovács, who performed a medical examination of the
boy two days later, reported the incident to the police. At first,
the parents were reluctant to file charges against the assailants
for fear of reprisal. However, with the aid of the local branch
of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina (VMSz), they went to
the police. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), June 10 and 11, 2004]
May
30, 2004
In
Törökkanizsa/Novi Knezevac, a private party organized
by young ethnic Hungarians in a rented house turned into a massive
street fight after a large group of Serbian youth arrived at the
scene. Earlier that evening, two Serbian young men had been told
that the party was a private affair. According to one party attendee,
they muttered "We'll be back!" as they left the house.
After the partygoers called the police, five cars arrived carrying
15-20 attackers. The uninvited group started to beat a small group
who had gone out for some fresh air. The new attackers claimed
that they had come to protect their friends, who had been assaulted
earlier. The fight ended only with the intervention of police
officers. Six ethnic Hungarian and two Serbian teenagers were
seriously injured and had to be hospitalized. The Knezevac branch
of the police has begun an investigation. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), June 1 and 3, 2004]
May
27, 2004
In
Szabadka/Subotica, six to seven young Serbian men attacked an
ethnic Hungarian teenager during the daytime in the downtown area.
The boy was walking home from school when the attackers approached
him and grabbed his bag, kicking his arms and back. The perpetrators
fled when the boy's father noticed the incident. The attack was
reported to the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina (VMSz) which
led VMSz President József Kasza and Chairman of
the Executive Committee Árpád Papp to visit
the chief of police. In an interview to the only Hungarian-language
daily Magyar Szó, police chief Borivoj
Mucalj claimed that after having investigated the incident,
the police found no signs of ethnic motivation. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), May 29-30
and June 2, 2004; Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), July 24-25, 2004]
May
22, 2004
In
Szabadka/Subotica, a group of eight Serbian young people attacked
three ethnic Hungarian teenagers, aged 18 and 19, on the main
square at 1:30 a.m. The victims were engaged in a conversation
in Hungarian at a popular local bar when a group of Serbian individuals
arrived. As the Hungarian teenagers grew apprehensive and left
the bar, the Serbian group followed them to the town hall street
corner. One of the victims said that they were outnumbered and
could not protect themselves. "I did not hit back, because
there were so many of them and I feared that I would receive even
more [blows]. I held up my arms to cover my face. I had no idea
why they started beating us and why they stopped. I think that
they were drunk. Maybe they had taken drugs and wanted to show
off. I am certain, however, that they beat us because we are Hungarians.
They heard us speak in Hungarian in front of the café.
We were not in their way; we tried to avoid them, but they followed
us," said the freshman university student who suffered bruises
and a black eye.
A
few days prior to this incident, Serbia's only Hungarian-language
daily, Magyar Szó, reported that a larger
group of Serbian youth provoked ethnic Hungarian high school students
in Subotica's downtown area near the theater. The victims
were beaten with baseball bats. In both cases, the ethnic Hungarian
teenagers were reluctant to tell their stories to the police for
fear of reprisal. In a subsequent interview with Magyar Szó,
police chief Borivoj Mucalj said that no one filed a report
about this case at the time, only a few days later, and by then
it was impossible to find the parties engaged in the fight. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), May 22, 2004;
Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), July
24-25, 2004]
May
3, 2004
In
Újvidék/Novi Sad, a group of young people harassed
members of the Adventist religious community participating in
an evening service, and assaulted two of its ministers who were
trying to defend believers from further attack. One of the ministers
was an ethnic Hungarian. The assailants were quickly taken into
police custody. A Ministry for Religious Affairs statement, released
subsequently, reiterated the right to freedom of religious expression.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
May 5, 2004]
April
17, 2004
Unidentified
perpetrators set the car of a man from Kosovo Polje on fire in
Újvidék/Novi Sad, causing damage of 100,000
Dinar (approx. $US 1,700). [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), April 20, 2004]
April
9, 2004
Béla
Csorba, Vice-President of the Hungarian Democratic Party
of Vojvodina (VMDP), found a 12-inch kitchen knife wrapped in
paper slipped under his door. Attached to the weapon was the following
message in Serbian: "We will slaughter you" (in Serbian:
"Zaklacemo vas"). Csorba reported the threatening note to the
police, who have begun an investigation. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), April 10-12, 2004]
April
5, 2004
József
Kasza, President of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina
(VMSz) and Miroljub Labus, Serbian Deputy Prime Minister
and President of the G17 political party, met -- at the initiative
of the former -- to discuss ethnic tensions in Vojvodina. Shockingly,
Labus asserted that neither police files nor the national media
had reports on any serious ethnic-based incidents or human rights
violations. Kasza proposed the establishment of a special government
committee consisting of local experts, including psychologists,
sociologists, doctors, and teachers, to develop tools promoting
tolerance and co-existence in the primary and secondary schools
of Vojvodina. Labus pledged to examine the proposal. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), April 7,
2004]
March
22, 2004
Nenad
Čanak, the President of the Vojvodina Parliamentary
Assembly, received a threatening letter for the second time this
year saying: "A death sentence on you came into force yesterday.
We are here to execute this sentence. Your disloyal career has
ended, and no one can help you." The letter was handwritten
and mailed from Nova Pazova, a city between Belgrade and
Novi Sad. An entity calling itself "The Serbian Diaspora Summary
Revolutionary Court," allegedly headquartered in Chicago, claimed
responsibility for the letter. This entity had sent similar letters
in the past to both Čanak and József Kasza,
who is President of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina (VMSz).
The last letter to Kasza stated: "You have been sentenced to
death for your attempt to separate Vojvodina from Serbia." [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), March
23, 2004]
March
17 and 18, 2004
Vojvodina
was marred by two days of province-wide demonstrations, vandalism
of minority-owned establishments, and incitement to hatred in
reaction to the wave of violence in Kosovo. Over 40 ethnic-based
incidents occurred between March 17-23, including hitherto unprecedented
attacks against ethnic Slovaks and Ruthenians. In the town of
Zombor/Sombor, 10 businesses including bakeries, shops and restaurants
run by ethnic Albanians were damaged. In a public statement, the
chairman of the municipal council, Jovan Vujicic,
linked his regret for these incidents to the wave of violence
against ethnic Serbs in Kosovo. On March 18, the Vojvodina Parliament
was the target of nationalistic demonstrations in the center of
Újvidék/Novi Sad. Speeches were made, and heckling
heard against Nenad Čanak, the President
of the Vojvodina Parliamentary Assembly. The flag of Vojvodina
Autonomous Province was torn from the assembly building. Police
mostly watched as crowds damaged a bakery owned by an ethnic Albanian,
although it did block roads once the organizers of the demonstration
(in three cars equipped with loudspeakers and bearing Novi Sad
and Roma registration plates, as well as one without any plates)
started to direct the masses towards the suburban enclaves of
Veliki Rit and Mali Beograd, well-known to be inhabited by Kosovo
refugees and Roma. However, enroute, the demonstrators were able
to shatter the windows of buildings, including those of the Novi
Sad Theater (a Hungarian cultural institution) and those belonging
to the headquarters of the Islamic religious community. The demonstrators
dispersed around 2:00 a.m. [Népszabadság
(Budapest), March 19, 2004; Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), March 21 and 23, 2004]
March
18, 2004
 |
A
Serbian neighbor and his son assaulted Tihamér
Lavró in the staircase of their house. Lavró
lives with his mother and a younger sister in a compound called
"Fighters Line-Up" in Szabadka/Subotica, an area with a
90 percent Serbian population, mainly refugees from Bosnia, Croatia
and Kosovo. On the day in question, Lavró was returning
home with a friend, who lives in the same building, when a Serbian
neighbor tripped and kicked him. The boys tried to escape via
the elevator, but the perpetrator blocked its outer door. While
the victim tried to protect himself by holding the inner door
of the elevator, the son of the assailant joined his father and
kicked in the inner door. After cornering the victim, they kicked
and beat the young man with a bicycle part until he passed out.
The victim was hospitalized with a concussion, facial fractions
and numerous bruises on his body. In the past, the father had
mocked the victim's ethnic origins, shouted insults about his
mother, shoved the victim's sister, and repeatedly vandalized
his car. Lavró and his family have been harassed daily
by this neighbor either by telephone or in person. Following the
victim's hospitalization, the son of the assailant threatened
the mother, saying that the next time Lavró will end up
in the morgue. Although police have begun an investigation, the
victim told reporters that he is pessimistic since a prior incident
involving the son is still under investigation after a year. The
only possible solution he sees is to move to another place. [HírTV
(Budapest) May 25, 2004 ]
 |
March
12, 2004
Three
Serbian boys assaulted Zsana Mészáros
in the local Miroslavan School in Palics/Palić during the
recess between classes. The boys kicked her in the back and continued
kicking after she fell to the ground. The girl was hospitalized
and an x-ray examination showed chipped cartilage. Months have
passed, but Mészáros has still not fully recovered
and might have complications in the future. Mészáros
and her mother told reporters that during the school investigation
several teachers tried to protect the boys by not giving out names
and telephone numbers. Mészáros' mother visited
the headmaster, who informed her that the boys were reprimanded
and the incident will be discussed at a school meeting. But the
school has not taken any action since the incident and Mészáros'
classmates continue to laugh at her and mock her Hungarian origin.
According to the mother, hate-speech is common in the fights that
take place between Serbian and Hungarian teenagers both in the
school and on the street. She also added that ethnic Hungarian
children are afraid to inform their parents or other adults because
they fear further violence. Parents feel desperate because they
believe that Serbian authorities will not intervene. [HírTV
(Budapest) May 20, 2004 ]
November
13, 2003
In
Szabadka/Subotica, three to four Serbian high school students
assaulted an ethnic Hungarian college student approximately 200
meters from the main post office at 10.00 p.m. The victim had
been speaking in Hungarian and the incident occurred after he
said goodbye to his friends at the post office and started walking
home alone. Suddenly, a group of Serbian teenagers grabbed him
from behind and started to pummel him. The assailants asked what
his name was. After it turned out that the victim's last name
was Serbian, the assailants said they would not hurt one of their
own people and left the scene. The student had to be hospitalized.
His father reported the incident to the police and the mayor's
office. The Hungarian-language daily Magyar Szó
pointed out in its article that ethnic-based incidents are becoming
a daily occurrence in the city's schools. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), November 18, 2003]
September
21, 2003
In
Temerin, five Serbian-speaking young men attacked and beat two
ethnic Hungarians, Tibor S. and Árpád Sz. in a restaurant
called "Pivarium." After the incident, which occurred around 11:20
p.m., one of the victims was hospitalized for several days. The
police found the assailants. [Béla Csorba, Vice-President
of the Hungarian Democratic Party of Vojvodina (VMDP),
Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), September
23, 2003]
August
26, 2003
Around
4:00 p.m. in Zenta/Senta, a local police officer was unwilling
to handle the case of an ethnic Hungarian citizen because he addressed
the policeman in Hungarian. The local resident went to the police
station to file a complaint against a neighbor who had hit him
that day and threatened his life. The neighbor was said to have
been terrorizing the entire neighborhood for more than six years
while the police neglected the case. When the local resident tried
to explain at the police what had happened, the policeman on duty
became agitated and, instead of processing the claim, shouted
at the man, asking him whether he knew he lived in Serbia, where
he must speak in Serbian. The resident was within his rights as
the Law on the Protection of the Rights and Liberties of National
Minorities establishes that a minority language can be used in
official communications in those communities which are at minimum
15 percent minority-inhabited. Zenta is a predominantly Hungarian-inhabited
town where the proportion of minorities exceeds 80 percent. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), September
1, 2003; Report by László Rácz Szabó
of Zenta/Senta]
March
8, 2003
After
a peaceful demonstration against the imposition of visa requirements
for Vojvodina Hungarians wishing to travel to Hungary, a group
of young ethnic Hungarians were walking towards a supermarket
on the outskirts of Szabadka/Subotica. A car with a Belgrade license
plate No. BG 148-03 passed by and suddenly stopped. Four to five
young Serbians jumped out of the car, grabbed the Hungarian flag
from one of the ethnic Hungarian teenagers, beat them and left
the scene immediately. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), March 11, 2003]
January
31, 2003
A
bus driver insulted an ethnic Hungarian teacher and her class
of 6-7 year-old primary school students on the No. 1 Klisa-Telep
bus line in Újvidék/Novi Sad. The teacher, and her
students from the local József Attila Elementary School,
were returning from a play. However, as soon as the children started
talking in Hungarian, the bus driver turned to the teacher and
told her that she should teach her pupils the "proper culture
and language." In response, the teacher called on the bus driver
not to say such incorrect things before the children. The bus
driver then began to shout and curse loudly, insulting the teacher
and the students. After the incident, the teacher reported the
case to the local authorities. After an examination of the incident,
the disciplinary committee of the Public Transport Company decided
to discipline the bus driver for intolerance exhibited against
passengers. However, Svetko Tanasic, the company's director,
denied any ethnic motivation to the incident. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), February 11 and 19, 2003]
III. Desecration
of Cemeteries, Vandalism of Property
|
HHRF's
expanded report contains 18 cases of desecration of Hungarian,
Croatian and Jewish cemeteries, historic sites and symbols,
and the vandalism of church and minority institutions sites.
The police are generally lax in investigating these incidents,
which are wide-spread. Their intent is seriously called
into question in those cases where they have allegedly identified
the perpetrators of massive damage in cemeteries to be minors,
often small children, and thus discontinued their investigations.
Two well-known cases occurred on March 27, 2004 and September
28, 2003. A related phenomena is the burning of the Hungarian
flag as happened during a soccer game in Újvidék/Novi
Sad on August 25, 2004. |
|
July
31, 2004
Unidentified
perpetrators threw Molotov-cocktails into a shop in Temerin during
the night. The street-level store belongs to Zoltán
Úri, an ethnic Hungarian, who lives in the same building
with his family. The fire caused extensive damage but since nothing
was stolen from the store, the perpetrators' motives remain unknown.
The police are still investigating the case. Locals believe that
it might be the act of nationalists who have been sending threatening
letters to certain ethnic Hungarians in the town postmarked from
Újvidék/Novi Sad, and who might be behind the flag-burning
incident of July 25. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), August 2, 2004]
July
3, 2004
 |
Unidentified
individuals desecrated 30-40 ethnic Croatian and Hungarian graves
in the St. Rókus Roman Catholic cemetery in Zombor/Sombor.
This was the third similar incident in the cemetery since 1995.
The grave of János Herceg, a prominent ethnic Hungarian
poet, was also desecrated. Josip Pekanovic, leader of the
Sombor/Zombor branch of the Croatian Democratic Community of Vojvodina,
was the first to learn about the incident. He reported the case
to the local police, the Croatian Consular office in Szabadka/Subotica,
and the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina. Police ignored demands
by the Croatian and Hungarian minority organizations to investigate
the incident. After numerous calls, the police registered only
17 of the total cases of desecration. Citing the lack of effort
made by the police authorities, József Kasza, President
of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina, called on Dragan
Jocic, Minister of the Interior, to resign. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), July 6, 7,
8 and 9, 2004]
July
3, 2004
Unidentified
persons twice desecrated graves in Monostorszeg/Backi Monostor
during the past four days. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), July 9, 2004]
May
29, 2004
Marjan
Medesi, aged 29, broke into the Catholic parish in Nagybecskerek/Zrenjanin
around 4:30 in the morning. The thief put valuables, cash amounting
to 1,970 Dinar (approx. $US 600) and a cell phone in a plastic
bag. He severely beat Jenő Tietze and his sister Adamina
who were trying to prevent the robbery. A criminal proceeding
is underway and the assailant's detention has been ordered. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), June 2, 2004]
May
2, 2004
In
Magyarkanizsa/Kanjiza, unidentified perpetrators vandalized the
Jewish cemetery, overturning a large marble monument erected originally
in 1948 to commemorate the town's 160 Holocaust victims. Paja
Vigoda, the cemetery's custodian, found the monument on the
ground, smeared with human excrement. Police have yet to investigate
the incident. Vigoda, who was appointed in 1996 by the Belgrade
Jewish Community to safeguard the cemetery, said it was not the
first time vandals had broken in. He said that no monies are allocated
for the restoration and preservation of the cemetery. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), May 5, 2004]
Meanwhile
in Törökbecse/Novi Becej, a total of 21 tombs (10 Roman
Catholic and 11 Orthodox) were vandalized and damaged in the local
cemetery. Two employees discovered the extensive damage in the
morning. A police investigation swiftly began and the perpetrator
was apprehended the next day, confessing to the crime. Authorities
said they will issue a statement shortly revealing the identity
of the perpetrator, who has numerous prior convictions. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), May 4 and 7,
2004; Magyar Nemzet (Budapest), May 05, 2004]
March
27, 2004
In
Szabadka/Subotica, perpetrators broke into the Roman Catholic
cemetery again, dislodging and destroying 82 wooden crosses and
10 stone decorations from Hungarian and Croatian graves. Three
days later, police issued an incredible statement: the perpetrators
had been caught: three children (A.F., D.T., and S.S.R.) between
the ages of seven and eight. The investigation was discontinued
even though children of that age and size would have been physically
incapable of inflicting the extent of damage which was caused
in the cemetery. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), March 29 and April 2, 2004]
March
18, 2004
Overnight,
unknown perpetrators vandalized and damaged a few graves in the
Roman Catholic cemetery located in the upper part of Zenta/Senta.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), March
19, 2004]
January
19, 2004
The
tomb of a five year-old girl was vandalized in the Roman Catholic
cemetery of Újvidék/Novi Sad. The perpetrators broke
the white marble tombstone probably with a hammer. The local branch
of the Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina issued a press release
demanding an end to such incidents. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), January 20, 2004]
January
13, 2004
Unknown
perpetrators broke into the Hungarian Reformed Church in Zombor/Sombor
sometime after Sunday, January 11. They vandalized the churchyard,
broke ornamentation on the church door, attempted to break into
the church itself and, in the end, flooded the church's cellar
with 120 cubic meters of water. By the time the minister arrived
back to the church on Tuesday afternoon, the church yard itself
was already flooding. Police responded immediately after the minister
called them, and continued investigating into the following morning.
Strangely, while the police were still at the scene on Wednesday
morning, unnamed minors were found to be kicking the church wall
and taking apart the brick fence. After an hour and a half of
questioning they were let go, and told that charges would be pressed
against them. On August 18, Andor Békássy,
minister of the church, told HHRF that he has not heard from the
police since the date of the incident seven months earlier. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/ Novi Sad), January
20, 2004]
January
5, 2004
A
marble cross at the entrance to the village of Kisbosznia/Mala
Bosna was damaged. The case was reported to the police who, after
questioning locals and consulting stone-carvers, concluded that
there was no ethnic motivation to the incident. Six month later,
after being queried about the incident by a Magyar Szó
reporter, Borivoj Mucalj, chief of police of
Szabadka/Subotica, stated that the cross had toppled because
it was old and close to the road. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/ Novi Sad), January
9, 2004; Magyar Szó (Újvidék/
Novi Sad), July 24-25, 2004]
February
4, 2004
In
Temerin, unknown perpetrators broke the bi-lingual sign identifying
the local Historical Museum. The museum has been a target for
Serb nationalists in the past. Two months ago, someone spray-painted
the name of the Serb Radical Party on the museum's door. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/ Novi Sad), February
5, 2004]
December
6, 2003
A
statue of Hungarian poet Antal Kovács, located a few meters
from the guard's post at the entrance to the Temerin town hall,
was spray-painted during the night. Similarly, the entrance door
of the local Szirmai Károly Hungarian Cultural Alliance (Szirmai
Károly Magyar Művelődési Egyesület) was also spray-painted
and, the name of the Serb Radical Party was emblazoned on the
door of the local Historical Museum. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/ Novi Sad), December 11, 2003]
November
26, 2003
More
than 50 wooden and stone crosses were damaged in a Roman Catholic
cemetery in Felsőmuzslya/Muzlja (a village neighboring Nagybecskerek/Zrenjanin).
On December 3, 2003 police arrested three minors -- L.N. (aged
17), N.K.(aged 16) and K.D.(aged 17) -- from Nagybecskerek/Zrenjanin.
One of the perpetrators, L.N., was placed under psychological
evaluation, the other, N.K., was seriously rebuked, while the
third perpetrator, K.D., was exempt from further examination.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/ Novi
Sad), November 27 and December 5, 2003]
October
5, 2003
At
7 a.m. in Grbavica (near Újvidék/Novi Sad), on the
corner of Tolstoy and Puskin Streets, three young Serbian men
aged 25-26 insulted Károly Nász and his wife,
sprinkling beer over the husband. The couple was saying goodbye
when the three, drunk men approached them. Hearing the spouses
speaking Hungarian, they spilled beer over Károly Nász,
started insulting them, and kicking their car. Nász called
the police but was unable to give an accurate description of the
aggressors due to his emotional state. Nász also told reporters
that a week ago his grandparents' grave was desecrated in the
Roman Catholic cemetery in Novi Sad. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/ Novi Sad), October 9, 2003]
September
28, 2003
During
the night, 86 graves were desecrated and severely damaged in the
Roman Catholic cemetery of Újvidék/Novi Sad. Several
crosses were overturned and tombstones uprooted. A 35year-old
grave of an infant, for example, was dug out half way after its
marble tombstone was removed. The total damage is estimated at
950,000 Dinars (approximately $US 15,800). Police began an investigation
and found the perpetrators: two minors, a girl (A.K.) and a boy
(M.P.) who are currently high school students. The perpetrators
admitted to the crime and said they were intoxicated at the time
of the act. The legal guardian of one of the perpetrators said
that police investigation was very controversial. At first, police
stated that both perpetrators' houses were searched in trying
to gather evidence for the crime. However, police did not in fact
come to their house. Secondly, it appears that more than two perpetrators
were involved in the incident. The legal guardian told the daily
Dnevnik that it is impossible for two minors --
a boy weighting 64 kg and a girl weighing 35 kg -- to cause such
extensive damage in only one hour (which was length of the incident
according to the police report). Before the judge, the two perpetrators
claimed that they damaged only a few crosses and graves but added
that a group of older boys had been watching them from the cemetery's
fence and also drinking. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/
Novi Sad), September 29 and 30, October 2, 7, November 8-9, 14
and 22-23, 2003]
April
16, 2003
In
Szabadka/Subotica, unknown perpetrators vandalized one of the
memorial stones in the Parcel No. 44 of the Zenta Street cemetery.
This section holds the engraving of the names of 29 innocent victims
of the 1944 massacres in Vojvodina. Local residents informed Ferenc
Sinkovits, President of the '44 Memorial Committee, who reported
the incident to the police. Last year one of the memorial stones
was also damaged along with the gate and fence of the section.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/ Novi
Sad), April 18, 2003]
February
1, 2003
In
the Roman Catholic cemetery of Újvidék/Novi Sad,
unknown perpetrators vandalized three tombstones. A police investigation
is underway. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/
Novi Sad), February 6, 2003]
IV. Proliferation
of Racist, Xenophobic and Anti-Semitic Graffiti
|
The
messages of graffiti found on homes as well as public institutions
explicitly incite to violence against minorities and contain
frequent use of the words "death to Hungarians," "slaughter,"
"go home," and "this is our land." The latter two messages
are particularly grotesque in light of the fact that while
the country has not adequately addressed the issue of hundreds
of thousands of internally displaced ethnic Serbians from
Croatia and Bosnia, Hungarians and other ethnic groups in
Vojvodina are autochthonous. The well-known and unmistakable
Serbian nationalistic acronym "CCCC" often accompanies these
warnings as do anti-Semitic symbols. HHRF's expanded report
contains 21 such incidents. |
|
NEW
September 28, 2004
In
Újvidék/Novi Sad, unidentified perpetrators spray-painted
graffiti on two columns of a building located in the projects
on Bata Brkic Street in the Újtelep District. One of the
text's was written in Cyrillic letters and stated "Death to
Hungarians" (in Serbian: "Smrt madjarima"); the other said
"Canak is an ustasha," referring to Nenad Canak, President
of the Vojvodina Assembly as being a Croatian facist. The Serbian
acronym with the four C-s separated in four fields by a cross
-- popular among Serbian nationalists -- was also left behind.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/NoviSad),
September 28, 2004]
NEW
September 24, 2004
Graffiti
stating "Death to Hungarians" (In Serbian: "Smrt
Madjarima") was spray-painted in red, Cyrillic letters on
a residential home located at No. 73 Sándor Petőfi Street
in Újvidék/Novi Sad. The Serbian nationalist acronym of four letter
"C"-s was also spray-painted next to the graffiti. The house belongs
to an ethnic Hungarian family living in the so-called "Telep District"
where most of the city's ethnic Hungarians live. Spokesman for
the Újvidék police, Stevan Krstic, told the
local Radio 021 that an investigation of the case
is underway. [Vajdaság MA -- Délvidék
Hírportál (www.vajdasagma.info),
September 24, 2004; Index (www.index.hu),
September 24, 2004]
NEW
September 15, 2004
At
night, unknown perpetrators imbedded a 35-cm kitchen knife into
the front door of the home of the Sötét family
of Szabadka/Subotica. Graffiti using Cyrillic letters and stating
"Death" and "Drop dead, Hungarians!" was also spray-painted
on the house, as well as the well-known Serbian nationalistic
acronym "CCCC." 13-year old Klementina Sötét
discovered the knife and the graffiti as she was walking to school
that morning. She ran back into the house, screaming that there
was blood on the door. The family reported the incident to the
police, which began an investigation. It also issued a short statement
stating that nationalistic and offensive graffiti -- there was
no mention of the knife in the statement -- appeared on a family
home's walls, targeting members of the ethnic Hungarian minority.
The incident came only 12 hours before Ferenc Mádl,
President of the Republic of Hungary's official visit to Szabadka
as the final destination.
 |
In
August, a group of ethnic Serbian youth assaulted 19-year old
Denisz Sötét at a bus stop near the Hotel Patria
in downtown Szabadka and he suffered numerous bruises and injuries
(see report of August 22, 2004 in Section I). Since he has gone
public with his story, Sötét's mother, Slavica, told
reporters that during the daytime a black car drives around their
home and sometimes stops at the house, reviving its engine. On
September 17, the five-member family abandoned their home and
left Vojvodina seeking political asylum in neighboring Hungary.
Only the Sötét's eldest son has remained in Szabadka.
This development came unexpectedly after both József
Kasza, Alliance of Hungarians in Vojvodina President, and
Hungarian President Mádl visited the family, urging
them to remain in Serbia. Currently, the Sötéts reside
in one of Hungary's three refugee camps, awaiting Hungarian authorities
to grant them political asylum. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), September 16, 18-19, 2004; Népszabadság
(Budapest), September 18, 2004]
August
25, 2004
A
group of 15 supporters of the Obilić (Belgrade) football
team set fire to the Hungarian national flag in Újvidék/Novi Sad
during a game between the Obilić and Vojvodina (Novi Sad)
teams. They also held up a banner with the slogan: "Temerin,
revenge, warriors" which they put aside when the police came.
The police escorted the instigators to the police station where
misdemeanor charges of misconduct were filed against two: Mihajlo
Milenović (aged 21) and Dalibor Marinovićot
(aged 26). Each paid a fine of 700 Dinars (approx. $US 11). Further
court proceedings are expected regarding the flag burning incident
as this constitutes a crime in Serbia and not merely a misdemeanor
according to the penal code. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), August 27, 2004]
July
25, 2004
Temerin
City Council Chairman, József Milinszky, issued
a statement informing the public about a flag-burning incident.
At 3:15 a.m., a local police officer on downtown patrol saw three
flags burning in front of the First Local Community's headquarters.
The Serbian, Hungarian and local flags had been put on display
the previous day as part of a festival. A police investigation
is underway. The desecration of national symbols is prohibited
by the penal code. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), July 26, 2004]
July
21, 2004
In
Nagybecskerek/Zrenjanin, graffiti offending sexual minorities
was spray painted on the wall of the local educational center.
The slogans said: "Go for a Serbia without homosexuals"
(in Serbian: "Za srbstvo bez pedera") and "Homosexuals are
not humans" ("Pedery nesu ludy"). A human rights activist
working for a civic organization housed in the building, and who
requested anonymity, said this was the first such offensive incident.
Members of the association include a variety of religious, national,
sexual and other minorities. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), July 22, 2004]
July
15, 2004
In
Újvidék/Novi Sad, a large anti-Hungarian graffiti appeared by
dawn on a concrete fence in front of a residence on the Ernő
Kiss Street. The epithet was spray painted with red colors, stating
"Okay, okay Hungarians -- a deep mass grave awaits you." Police
have begun an investigation. [Magyar Szó
(Újvidék/Novi Sad), July 16, 2004]
May
2, 2004
Nationalistic
and anti-Semitic graffiti appeared again on several downtown buildings
in the capitol of Vojvodina Province, Újvidék/Novi
Sad. Inscriptions such as "Serbia belongs to Serbs," "Out with
Hungarians," as well as anti-Israel slogans and crossed out
Stars of David were found. László Galambos,
Vice President of the local chapter of the Alliance of Hungarians
in Vojvodina told reporters that such incidents occur daily in
the city. [Krónika (Cluj/Kolozsvár,
Romania), May 6, 2004]
April
19, 2004
Citing
a statement issued by the Újvidék/Novi Sad Police,
the Beta News Agency reported that graffiti instigating
against Hungarians appeared on the pavement in front of the house
at 34 Népfront Street in Temerin. [Vajdaság MA
-- Délvidék Hírportál (www.vajdasagma.info),
April 19, 2004]
"Let's
Slaughter Hungarians" (in Serbian: "pobijmo madjare") was the
message spray painted on a train and highway bridge in Újvidék/Novi
Sad. Mayor Borislav Nosakovic condemned the incident, promised
to remove the graffiti and called on authorities to apprehend
the perpetrators. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), April 20, 2004]
April
9, 2004
"Death
to Hungarians" (in Serbian: "Smrt madjarima") was the graffiti
spray painted on a store and bakery located at the corner of Tito
Marshall and Dusan Guconja Streets in the center of Bácsföldvár/Backo
Gradiste. The officially approved Serbian-Hungarian bilingual
road sign was also removed and replaced with a Serbian-language
one. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
April 10-12, 2004]
April
2, 2004
Anti-Hungarian
graffiti appeared in the town of Zenta/Senta stating "Death to
Hungarians" and "This is Serbia." The graffiti was found on a
Hungarian historic monument and two place name signs. Local police
and town officials have failed to investigate the incident. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), April 6, 2004]
Anti-Hungarian
graffiti was reported on four buildings in Szabadka/Subotica:
on the wall of the local sports arena, stating "Hungarians, go
to Hungary" (see picture on the left), the Hungarian cultural
house, Népkör, stating "We will kill you, Hungarians"
(see picture on the right), the Szent Teréz Cathedral and the
Lazar Neąić high school. The writings were all in the Cyrillic
alphabet. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), April 3-4, 2004]
March
8 and 17, 2004
Anti-Hungarian
graffiti appeared on a Hungarian decoration in a school in Csóka/Coka.
The graffiti stated: "Out from Serbia! This is our home! You
do not belong here!" (in Serbian: "Idite iz Srbije ove je
nasa zemlja ovde niste dobrodosli"). A week after the message
was removed, new ones appeared stating: "Out from Serbia!"
(Idite iz Srbije), "Serbia: Extend to Tokyo"
(Srbija do Tokija). Local police and town officials have failed
to investigate the incident. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), March 12 and 17, 2004]
October
17, 2003
At
the Gynecological Clinic in Újvidék/Novi Sad, the
personnel insulted an expectant mother, B.B., for speaking in
Hungarian. The young woman was sent to the clinic for examinations
and escorted by her husband because she doesn't speak Serbian
well. The required examination was high-risk, to be performed
only in the 16th week of pregnancy. First, the receptionist
at the clinic objected to the husband speaking for his wife and
later started yelling at him that "he should have taught her Serbian."
The treatment the young mother received from three examining nurses
was the same. They admonished her that "we will teach you Serbian!".
Finally, the nurses yelled so much at the patient that B.B. left
the clinic crying and without having the procedure done. Afterwards,
the patient's gynecologist from Szabadka/Subotica, dr. Slavica
Mazak Beąlić, tried to intervene with the director of
the institution, dr. Vule Viąnjevac. The director's retort
was that she should teach her patients Serbian before sending
them to the clinic. Sándor Egeresi, Vice-President
of the Vojvodina Parliamentary Assembly, reported the incident
to the Ombudsman of Vojvodina, dr. Petar Teofilović.
Subsequently, the director of the clinic, dr. Viąnjevac was removed,
and a new director, dr. Milenko Bujas, appointed. However,
the central director of the Clinical Center in Novi Sad said that
the change did not occur as a result of the above-described incident.
[Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad),
October 17, 18-19 and 25-26, 2003]
September
10, 2003
Jovan
Pejin, historian and member of the Serbian People's Movement,
accused Hungarians, Slovaks and Romanians of "occupying" Serbian
territory in Vojvodina since the 10th Century. The diatribe was
broadcast during primetime over Novi Sad Television during the
"Otkopcano" (Unfastened) program. The Hungarian Alliance of Vojvodina
(VMSz) protested this effort to undermine the peaceful coexistence
of 26 ethnic groups in Vojvodina. [Press Release of the Hungarian
Alliance of Vojvodina, September 16, 2003]
August
30, 2003
Graffiti,
carved into the asphalt, appeared on the main street of Temerin,
in front of houses inhabited by ethnic Hungarians. The message
said: "Death to Hungarians" (in Serbian: Smrt Mađarima) and
was signed: "Serb Chetniks" (Srpski četnici). The local branch
of the Hungarian Democratic Party of Vojvodina (VMDP) condemned
the act and called upon the authorities to take effective measures.
[Press Release of the Hungarian Democratic Party of Vojvodina,
September 2, 2003]
June
2003
In
mid-June, unknown perpetrators spray-painted graffiti saying "Serbia
is a Pravoslavic country" (in Serbian: "Srbija je pravoslavna
zemlja") in Cyrillic letters on the wall of the Hungarian Reformed
Church in Zombor/Sombor. [ First-hand Report from the Resident
Minister, Rev. Andor Békássy, dated August 18, 2004]
March
10, 2003
On
Monday, March 10, graffiti saying: "This is Serbia" (Ovo
je Srbija), written in Cyrillic letters, appeared on the walls
of the Széchenyi István Elementary School in Szabadka/Subotica.
This school conducts its classes in Hungarian and has mostly ethnic
Hungarian students. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), March 11, 2003]
March
7, 2003
In
Szabadka/Subotica, anti-Hungarian graffiti appeared on the walls
of the Hungarian cultural house, Népkör,
and a private house facing the Újvidék/Novi Sad
University's branch Faculty of Economics. The message read: "Hungarians
leave from here to the beautiful green Hungary!" (In Serbian:
"Mađari, kuą u Mađarsku, lepu zelenu"). In the morning,
when the graffiti was spotted, employees of Népkör
called the police, who arrived within 15 minutes, and began an
investigation. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), March 8, 2003]
January
18, 2003
Residents
of the district called "Telep," a predominantly Hungarian inhabited
area of Újvidék/Novi Sad, found a number of flyers
on their cars inciting to hatred against Hungarians. The flyers
were hand-written and they contained the following text: "Since
we appreciate the good neighborly relations with Hungary we want
the green stars [a term for ethnic Hungarians] living in Southern
Bácska to go to the lovely green Hungary." A clover,
the letter "M," as well as a green-colored five-pointed star were
also inscribed on the pamphlets. A police investigation is underway.
President of the Vojvodina Parliamentary Assembly Nenad Čanak
condemned the incident. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), January 21, 2003]
V. Vandalism
of Multi-Lingual Signs
|
On
August 16, 2003, the official Hungarian National Council
of Vojvodina, established in 2002, adopted a resolution
governing the use of Hungarian locality names in the province.
This act was brought in accordance with the Article 7, Paragraph
1 of the Provincial Assembly's resolution on official use
of national minority languages. Accordingly, the Hungarian
names of localities can be posted, and the Hungarian language
used in public administration, in those communities where
the proportion of the Hungarian population exceeds 15 percent.
Thus, the common practice and right afforded by the 1974
Yugoslav Constitution -- to post multi-lingual signs of
all nationalities inhabiting an area -- has been restored
in the province. The defacement and vandalism of these new
bi- or multi-lingual signs is such a widespread occurrence
that only a handful of cases are ever reported. |
|
May
15, 2004
Residents
of Tiszaszentmiklós/Ostijicevo discovered that during the
night unidentified vandals had painted over the Hungarian name
of the village on all the bi-lingual signs identifying the village.
The Latin and Cyrillic Serbian versions of the name were left
intact. Police have not investigated the incident. [First-hand
report from the Mayor of Csóka, Zoltán Margit,
May 16, 2004]
April
2, 2004
Two
of the road signs identifying Zenta/Senta were vandalized during
the night of April 2. Vandals spray-painted the text "Smrt Mađarima"
(Death to Hungarians) on one, and "Ovo je Srbija" (This
is Serbia) on the other. A well-known Serbian nationalist acronym
"CCCC" is also visible. [Magyar Szó (Újvidék/Novi
Sad), April 6, 2004 ]
February
2004
For
weeks the sign indicating the entrance to the village of Kisorosz/Rusko
Selo has been vandalized regularly. The Hungarian version of the
name is painted over during the night, and later reapplied by
the locals. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), February
16, 2004]
February
13, 2004
Unknown
vandals spray-painted over the Hungarian name of Magyarkanizsa/Kanjiza
on all four road signs identifying the town. Inhabitants are perplexed
by the timing of the incident since these official bilingual signs
have been posted for several months. [Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), February
14-15, 2004]
March
8, 2003
Unknown
perpetrators spray-painted over the Hungarian name of Szabadka/Subotica
on both the entrance and exit road signs identifying the town.
The graffiti appeared at the northern part of the town, on the
road leading to Palics/Palić. [ Magyar
Szó (Újvidék/Novi Sad), March
11, 2003]
|
Copyright
© 2004 Hungarian Human Rights Foundation |
|